[Download] ➸ Bandersnatch Author Diana Pavlac Glyer – Horse-zine.co.uk

Bandersnatch summary Bandersnatch , series Bandersnatch , book Bandersnatch , pdf Bandersnatch , Bandersnatch a12adb1eaf A Look At The Inklings And Their Creative ProcessCS Lewis, JRR Tolkien, And The Inklings Met Each Week To Read And Discuss Each Other S Work In Progress, Offering Both Encouragement And Blistering Critique How Did These Conversations Shape The Books They Were Writing How Does Creative Collaboration Enhance Individual Talent And What Can We Learn From Their Example

10 thoughts on “Bandersnatch

  1. says:

    Copy provided by Kent State University Press.In The Company They Keep, Diana Pavlac Glyer established herself among the foremost Inklings scholars It s one of those rarities, a deeply academic book that is also immensely readable That book proved that the Inklings really were a collaborative group, and not a bunch of lone geniuses who got together regularly to read bits then retreated to their man caves for solitary labor.In Bandersnatch, she shows how they did it To do so, Glyer uses that clear, accessible style to begin with her own search for the Inklings process, and how long it took before she cracked the case She then develops an overview of the Inklings various backgrounds, and how they came together to form the group Next she explores with an eye to writers today who may be looking for ways to form and run a successful writers group how the Inklings worked, and what eventually broke the group.What bound them together for so long was the question they all faced on arrival, Well, has nobody got anything to read to us Everybody got their innings, whether the work was abstruse poetry, a linguistic paper, a history, or fiction Everyone was free to criticize, and according to Warren Lewis, it might have sounded like a battleground as all these articulate, trenchantly intellectual and rigorously trained men picked apart ideas, but there was no rancor nor striving to force others to one s POV They did get picky about who could join, sometimes getting irritated if a member brought a guest without consulting the rest Though one or two of these guests eventually fit right in.They despised the idea of a mere butter bath nothing but praise, and Glyer makes it clear in a succession of chapters who influenced various famous works, and how And not always for the best at least, I liked the ending for LOTR that Tolkien wanted better than the one we have, but he bowed to what he perceived as universal disapprobation for his own wishes When JRRT began writing what became LOTR it was called the new Hobbit for years C.S Lewis was excited by the idea, but he said the beginning bogged down in a lot of hobbit talk This grieved Tolkien, as he loved his hobbits, and his idea of a good hobbit book included lots of hobbits gossiping, eating, gardening, and pottering about the Shire.But JRRT got stuck early on and couldn t move on the book for several years, until he had lunch with Lewis, who pointed out that hobbits are only amusing in unhobbit like situations Bang That was exactly what Tolkien needed, and the book took off In another discussion, Glyer illustrates how Lewis was convinced that no good book can be good for kids unless it is also good for adults This is a children s book only in the sense that the first of many readings can be undertaken in the nursery .Only years later, at a tenth or a twentieth read, will they begin to realize what deft scholarship and profound reflection have gone to make everything in it so ripe, so friendly, and in its own way so true He plainly tried to put that to work in his Narnia series which Tolkien loathed Lewis gave up the idea until he got encouragement from Roger Lancelyn Green, who adored the first book and Lewis went back to it Narnia s mishmash of mythologies and the overt religious symbolism were never going to appeal to Tolkien, whose religious convictions resonated tectonically in his work, the fictional landscape above shaped by a painstakingly consistent mythology But Tolkien reined in his general objection, and either gave specific feedback or else just listened without comment.Glyer also uses the Inklings to illustrate what can kill a group Some of the Inklings, including Owen Barfield, didn t care for Lord of the Rings, but kept silent when it was Tolkien s turn to read But Hugo Dyson, a man they all liked and respected, loathed LOTR so much he would complain loudly if Tolkien showed up with papers now they were in for another load of elves His complaints were so loud and consistent that Tolkien stopped reading when Dyson showed up and though none of them knew it at the time, that was the breaking point of the Inklings Glyer illustrates the fundamental difference between keeping silence, and silencing someone.At the end of each chapter is a concise set of suggestions for the writer either on process or as part of a writers group, and it ends with a terrific meditation on collaboration in the wider sense There s an excellent quote from Dorothy Sayers Poets do not merely pass on the torch in a relay race they toss the ball to one another, to and fro, across the centuries Dante would have been different if Virgil had never been, but if Dante had never been, we should know Virgil differently across both their heads Ezekiel calls to Blake, and Milton to Homer The book ends with a list of sensible and workable suggestions for putting together a writers group.I think this book would be ideal for any writer with sympathy or interest in at least one of the Inklings It would also be an excellent text for a writers class, especially within the framework of Christian schools, as the Inklings were Christians, so there is necessarily discussion of Christian viewpoints But I think there is a great deal of insight and practical suggestion for anybody here, unless you happen to be one of those who has to stick fingers in ears and shout La La La when a discussion veers toward sympathy with religion.The book is also handsomely illustrated by James A Owen.

  2. says:

    Community is all the rage these days There s the atheist community and the art community, the scrapbooking community and the UFO community, the homeless community and the homeschool community But having a common interest or grievance does not forge a set of disconnected individuals into a genuinely connected union Churches, too, if you re into that kind of thing, have started using the term community a lot, though we pretty much just mean the same thing as when we talked about our membership Diana Glyer s new book, Bandersnatch, is not just, as New York Times book reviewer Mark Oppenheimer said in a different context, another way to finger C S Lewis and J R R Tolkien s shroud, not simply another book about the beer and pipe group of what Malcolm Guite has called tweed covered Oxford dons Glyer studies the Inklings to find the genius that allowed this boisterous group of strong personalities to form a true community that provided the encouragement, opposition, praise, criticism, and fun that sustained what is now being understood as perhaps the only truly counter cultural, revolutionary writer s group of the mid twentieth century Bandersnatch could be read alongside the Rule of St Benedict as a handbook for forming true community For churches wishing to form genuinely dynamic small groups, for pastors feeling the isolation of their calling and seeking a new wind in their sails, for Christian students striving courageously on the campuses of hostile secular universities, this is not an entertaining diversion but a field manual for the battle.

  3. says:

    My only complaint is the lack of chronology Everything else was incredible I expected the book to be a biography on the Inklings group and it is that, as the author had the context to understand the members and their writings.But than the WHO, the book addresses the HOW of the group How did the Inklings impact one another How did the group operate and for so long The most impactful part for me was the WHY Why did they have a group at all And why on earth did it become the writing group of the 21st century Bandersnatch explores the very nature of community and how the Inklings achieved a proper balance for such a long while It s than a biography it s a study of creativity and community As a writer, it s an invaluable insight into one of the most influential groups of modern times and a highly practical inspiration.

  4. says:

    Rating 3.5 of five, rounded up for the scrummy illustrationsIt s Booksgiving Start getting your bookish friends their read onthis book is perfect for your LotR obsessed friend who s read every word Tolkien wrote already.Diana Pavlac Glyer, author of the also excellent The Company They Keep C.S Lewis and J.R.R Tolkien as Writers in Community, gives us a combination of cautionary tale for writers groups, a group biography of the Inklings, and a meditation on what creativity, in the end, costs, means, and does I love the illustrations My full review is at Expendable Mudge Muses Aloud.

  5. says:

    CALLING ALL TOLKIEN AND LEWIS FANS This book tells the story of Lewis and Tolkien s friendship and how it brought about so much of their widely read work If you re wondering who wanted to punch who when they first met, this book is for you My basic knowledge of these two great writers was enriched from reading this book There are men behind the mythologies, get to know them.

  6. says:

    This is much than just a popular version of Glyers great Scholarly work on the Inkings The Company They Keep this is a book that encourages new writers just as much as it tells the story of great writers in the past its a call to collaboration full of inspiring stories and practical tips, so that we not only admire the Inklings as a writers group, we are given every opportunity and encouragement to learn from them

  7. says:

    I enjoyed this book for many reasons for its stories of the workings of the Inklings, for its insights into the creative process, and for its practical suggestions for writers and other creative people.For those who love the works of J R R Tolkien and C.S Lewis, could anything be inspiring than to enter into the creative relationship of these two friends to see how they influenced one another This book opens a door to that friendship and to the relationships among the other members of the Inklings to show what a creative difference these writers made to one another.Bandersnatch is fascinating not only as literary history, but it will also show you ways to transform your own creative life by inviting others into it.

  8. says:

    Multitudes of readers and movie goers are familiar with the names and writings of C.S Lewis and J.R.R Tolkien Many are also aware that the two literary giants were part of a club called The Inklings, though they may not know anything about the group Fewer realize that there were well over a dozen Inklings, although some have heard of Christopher Tolkien, Charles Williams, and Owen Barfield Hardly anyone can name all nineteen, and perhaps nobody has read every single thing ever published by every single one of them except Dr Diana Glyer From the treasure houses of knowledge accumulated over twenty plus years of meticulous research, Dr Glyer presents in Bandersnatch a well balanced blend of trustworthy factual information and thoughtful insight regarding the individuals who were the Inklings, their personal interactions with one another, and both the public and private workings of the group as a corporate body The dual nature of this book makes it particularly helpful it is not only a genuinely good, accessible biography of the Inklings it is also an excellent, encouraging guidebook for those who wish to follow their example Each chapter concludes with a succinct Doing What They Did summary, and the final section of the book is an epilogue outlining specific steps for starting a writing group.Bandersnatch is both a significant contribution to Inklings scholarship and a valuable resource on collaborative creativity I highly recommend it to Inklings lovers as well as writers and other artists seeking to live and create in community.

  9. says:

    A glory upon glory If Diana Pavlac Glyer s monumental The Company They Keep weren t enough to establish her in the echelon of the very best thinkers and writers on the Inklings, along comes Bandersnatch to cinch the deal for scholars and general readers alike, mapping out a collaborative model that cannot help but enrich every life lucky enough to delve into its pages A MUST HAVE, for many re reads, for years to come

  10. says:

    How shall I start this post How about this book is fabulous, interesting, encouraging and a must read for Inkling fans and writers Yes, let s start there I m going to continue by saying I absolutely loved this book This is a fabulously read for Inklings fans as well as writers Let me get back to the Inklings part The insiders look into the key members of the Inklings is fascinating to read like what Tolkien and Lewis thought of each other s works I really enjoyed learning about how they thought, what they liked, etc and how that all played a role in the ways they critiqued How they meet, how the group grew and how they encouraged and critiqued each other is a lesson anyone can use no matter the industry they work I loved that this book was written for all readers and reminds readers why we love story in the first place There are also key takeaways of what it looks like to collaborate Praise and criticism are necessary because they help you grow as a writer I enjoyed all of it, but especially enjoyed reading Tolkien and Lewis responses and encouragement to both praise and criticism I m sure that has to do with the fact that I m a bit of a fan of the two, but no matter this book is a must read for collaborators The Inklings were by no means a perfect group, delivering criticism with perfection or anything like that, but they worked through it and truly everyone was a better writer because of it.Oh and y all she s met and talked with Christopher Tolkien Wha Have you had the chance to study or learn from some of your favorite authors Thank you to the author for a copy of the book in exchange for my honest review Originally posted at

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *